Not every bad review on your profile came from a real customer.
Bad reviews rarely turn up one at a time. They come in clusters. Your best chef left, storm season shut you for a fortnight, a supplier let you down for weeks. Real customers had a genuinely rough experience during that stretch and said so, fairly.
Then, buried in that same batch, sits one review from someone who was never actually there. A competitor’s account. A former staff member with a grudge. Someone who’s simply mixed you up with a business two suburbs over. Because it landed alongside the real complaints, it looks exactly the same at first glance.
This is where most owners get it wrong, in both directions. Some try to get every bad review removed, get knocked back across the board, and assume nothing can be done. Others accept the whole batch as fair and leave a fabricated post sitting there for years, never realising it was never real. We start by sorting the two apart, because you can’t act sensibly on either group until you know which is which.
Send us your profile and we’ll sort it.
All inquiries responded within 24 hours
A real customer usually has some history behind their account, other businesses reviewed, other ratings left. An account created days before it reviewed you, with nothing else on it, is a completely different situation, no matter how convincing the complaint sounds.
Genuine complaints from a genuinely bad patch scatter naturally across weeks. Planted reviews tend to cluster together into hours instead.
This is where most cases actually get settled. A booking, an invoice, a job sheet. Either something matches the date and service in the review, or nothing does.
Text that also shows up on other businesses, or names a competitor directly, isn't genuine feedback.
Plainly, without softening it. If four of the six negative reviews bothering you describe the same real problem, that's worth knowing far more than it's worth arguing with.
Removable, arguable, and legitimate, three lists laid out clearly, with reasoning behind each one. Yours to keep whether you engage us further or not.
A look at genuine cases, showing what changed once the fake reviews were separated out and removed.
A cancelled sailing or a washed-out week generates real disappointment, and a competitor's fake review slots quietly into the same run, almost invisible among the honest complaints.
Service genuinely dips while a new kitchen finds its feet, and that dip is the easiest possible cover for a planted post.
Everyone's backed up, wait times blow out, genuine complaints follow, and somewhere among them sits a fake review for a job you never even quoted.
Emotionally charged, sometimes written by people who aren't even the client, and hard to answer publicly without breaching confidentiality.
Peak season stress produces real complaints, and rivals know it's the best time to slip in a fake one.
A long wait or a billing dispute is fair feedback. A description of a procedure you don't even offer is something else entirely.
Complaints meant for another branch, or aimed at the brand rather than your store, get mixed in and unfairly drag your rating down.
Dense competition and high staff turnover mean genuine variability in service and a steady supply of fake accounts looking to do damage.
Once you suspect some reviews are fake, it's easy to dismiss all criticism, even the fair kind. That's how a real, fixable problem can sit unaddressed for two years.
Reporting genuine complaints doesn't just fail on its own. Repeated weak reports make your future legitimate reports look less credible to Google over time.
Fake reviews are usually written to be maximally damaging. They accuse rather than describe, which makes them stand out and get quoted more readily in summaries.
Properly sorting the pile takes an afternoon. Not sorting it can cost you a full year of a distorted rating and a real problem left untouched.
The test is never whether a review is fair or proportionate. It’s whether it genuinely breaks a rule, probably.
Removable: No Genuine Connection to Your Business
The reviewer was never a customer, and your records show no matching job or booking anywhere.
Clusters of ratings from new accounts with no history, arriving within a suspiciously tight window.
Links, phone numbers, or text duplicated across several unrelated listings.
Named staff, personal attacks, discriminatory language, or threats.
Complaints about a different business, or an incident that never happened on your premises.
Even a blunt one. Even one from a stretch you'd rather forget. That review stays, and the right response is a thoughtful reply and a genuine fix, never a doomed removal request.
"I've never used this business, but I would not recommend them to anyone in Queensland. Stay away from this company."
"Don't use this business. I provide better services at a lower price. Check my profile and contact me directly for a quote."
"This business is dishonest and should be avoided. I've never been a customer, but people across Queensland should stay away from them."
Every review goes into one of three groups, with account analysis and reasoning behind each placement.
For genuinely removable reviews, we build a submission naming the exact clause breached, with real evidence attached, including whatever your own records confirm.
Submitted through Google's official channels only, followed up on properly, and escalated wherever a rejection doesn't hold up. We never submit once and call it done.
Nothing else needed to start. No account access, no credentials.
For each suspect review, you confirm whether a matching record exists. Usually a short job, and it's what decides most cases.
Nothing gets filed without your approval, and you can pull any case at any point.
Filing dates, Google's responses, and every escalation, timestamped clearly, without having to ask us.
Fabricated posts come off permanently, not just diluted by newer reviews sitting on top.
With the fake material gone, what's left is real customers telling you something true, even when it stings a little.
Review signals feed directly into search results, so a corrected average tends to lift where you appear.
Once you've seen how the sorting works, the next suspicious review is much easier to spot and flag on your own.
If most of the reviews hurting your rating turn out to be legitimate, we'll say so. Not always what an owner wants to hear, but far more useful than a removal campaign that was always going to fail.
No mass-flagging, no vague reports. Each submission points directly at a specific breach, with real evidence attached.
Failed cases cost nothing, which keeps us genuinely selective about which cases we take on.
The policy clause and the full account analysis come to you in complete detail, every time.
Google's own reporting system, without exception. The shortcuts that get listings suspended aren't worth the risk.
We also help build genuine review volume afterwards, because a steady flow of real feedback is what stops one fake post from ever mattering this much again.
Send us your Google Business Profile. We’ll sort every review into what genuinely breaches Google’s rules, what’s arguable, and what’s fair criticism you’re better off answering yourself. Free, in writing, with nothing owed either way.
Leading reputation management and digital growth agency trusted by 900+ clients worldwide.
© 2026 Erase Trax. All rights reserved.